Compare natural gas water heating costs to electricity for your area. Disadvantages of Gas Water Heaters. They cost more upfront and can be more expensive to maintain. We hope this is useful if you’re interested in heating your pool or just considering options for your future pool. It is possible that heat pump pool heating systems may be banned (or heavily taxed) in Ontario. The largest heat pump pool heater typically produces 30% of the heat that the smallest gas heater produces. There are a few different methods to heat your above ground pool. A gas water heater offers more accurate temperatures and is able to heat the water at a faster pace. Electric heat pumps are, amazingly, actually a form of solar energy. Using the sun’s energy, the existing pool pump circulates the water through the heater, which is typically located on the rooftop or on a frame constructed in the yard. As spring rolls around and winter comes to a close, it’s time to begin opening pools or having new pools installed. Gas heaters are particularly popular in cold climates, where they can greatly extend the swimming season. 2000W Floating Electric Heater Boiler Water Heating Element Portable Immersion Suspension Bathroom Swimming Pool AU/EU/UK Plug. You have two main choices: a gas-fired pool heater or an electric pool heat pump. Gas-fired heaters do the job by pumping the water through the heater and using gas heat to warm the water before it is pumped back into the pool. At 3 Day Pools we meet with hundreds of families across Ontario and within the GTA each year regarding their inground pool projects and we receive many questions regarding pool heaters. Electric heaters (also referred to as heat pumps) heat the pool water by cycling it through a pump which takes the outside air and transfers the heat into the water via the refrigeration cycle. These are the three options available not including not having a heater at all. Both electric and gas pool heaters should have proper ventilation if they are housed indoors. by NYW ... Hayward H250FDN Universal H-Series 250,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Natural Gas, Low Nox. They can be bulky and take up more space than an electric water heater. These are the most common types of heater in the industry and a primary reason for this is cost. Regardless of your location, at some point you’ll probably consider heating when making decisions for your pool. Pool Heaters: Gas Heaters vs. Electric Heat Pumps. Your pool water runs through copper coils and returns to the pool warm. However, electric heat pumps also require proper ventilation, since heat pumps take the surrounding air to heat the pool. The installer, which is an old school type of guy, swears by the gas heater. Keep your pool warm this summer with one of our pool heaters. As a pool heater may be the biggest investment into your pool equipment, you want to ensure you make the right choice and with so many different options on the market it can get confusing. Heating is required to keep the water temperatures warm and enjoyable. Using a gas fired pool heater in this manner would get very expensive very fast. ©2021 Emerson Electric Co. All rights reserved. Both electric and gas pool heaters should have proper ventilation if they are housed indoors. I am looking to heat pool to 85 for 3 months of the summer. These controls may be individual or combined into one control and are designed to protect the compressor. Gas Pool Heaters. However, if you live in a location with colder climates, a heat pump would need to use more energy since it needs to draw in heat from the outside air. Gas: A gas pool heater is the most common type because it heats a pool quickly and effectively. Fast and free shipping across Canada on all pool heaters and heat pumps. The water is heated when it passes through the coils. Gas heaters heat your pool by burning natural gas or propane. Great question! Hello. For more information on the pool heater types in Toronto (and other pool accessories) gives a call for a free consultation and quote. This makes them a good choice for users who live in areas where the temperature may not remain above freezing and also works well for those who only heat their pools during certain times of the year. They function like your home gas furnace. Electric heat pumps can extend the average pool use by 2-3 months depending on location. The size of the pool, location/climate, frequency of use, efficiency, and cost are all variables that should impact the buying decision. We all know how much kids enjoy the swimming pool, and closing time can be a bummer, but with a pool heater you and your family can maximize the fun. This heater requires temperatures of approximately 55°F (12°C) or higher to function properly. Your email address will not be published. According to a study called “An Examination of the Opportunity for Residential Heat Pumps in Ontario” by the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO), the operating costs of heating systems are complex and depend on a number of factors, including: 1. However, electric heat pumps also require proper ventilation, since heat pumps take the surrounding air to heat the pool. Pool heaters circulate water and use heating coils to raise the temperature by burning gas, typically propane or natural gas. In summary, either is possible to house indoors, but it is not advised unless the proper safety measures are taken to do so. While solar pumps may be “free,” you still have to leave the pump running in order for it to function. Without proper ventilation, the heat pump will re-circulate the same air. 0 Reviews. When cost and energy efficiency are key, we give you the best practices to address your structure’s HVAC needs. Bad news all around. Therefore, proper ventilation is important in order to help the electric heat pump run more efficiently. Premium brand pool heaters and heat pumps at discounted prices. A natural gas water heater saves you approximately $180* a year compared to electric. When it comes to energy efficiency let us look into how each type works.The gas heater produces approximately 800w of heat from 1 kw of gas. Your email address will not be published. By meeting EF standards, they can be considered energy efficient. The gas burns inside a combustion chamber that contains a series of copper coils. Should we go with our gut and get the electric heat pump or follow the professional’s suggestion with gas? Thanks, Typically gas heaters are used in northern climate whiles heat pump pool heaters are used in the southern US. Plus they cost much more to install, don't last as long, can be noisy and put a peak load on the electrical grid - just when the utilities don't want it! The average cost of a gas pool heater is between $1,500 and $2,500. This heater makes use of a heater pump, which many consider as an eco-friendly option. Much like a pot of water on a gas stove, you can deliver a lot more heating performance to water with gas than electric. this nifty savings calculator created by AquaComfort, The 5 Things Every Pool Shopper needs to know Before they receive any Estimates, Four Important Fiberglass Pool Warranty Questions, Different Types of Fiberglass Pool Installations Costs, What You Need to Know About Fiberglass Pool Gelcoat Surface. Extend your season and get the most use out of your pool this year with one of our powerful pool heaters from industry leading manufacturers. CDN$ 2,499.00. What would you like to learn more about? Because of this we now often install electric heat pumps over gas heaters for our new in-ground pool customers as these families anticipate lots of use of their new pool installation. Gas heaters are less expensive to purchase and install than heat pumps, driving many homeowners to opt for gas. Hayward by Hayward. Some popular heaters sold locally are rated at … This process allows heat pumps to use less energy and operate more efficiently than their gas counterpart. In Ontario, a heat pump now costs twice as much in electricity as a gas heater does in gas to deliver the same amount of heat. An Electric Pool Heater is another great option, if propane or natural gas won't work for your pool. Nowadays, options for heating swimming pools are a bit more efficient: homeowners usually choose either a gas/propane pool heater or an electric heat pump to achieve the perfect temperature. In order to use a gas heater, you’ll need to have a gas line running to your home. AC & Heating Connect was established to provide timely and accurate information about air conditioning and equipment, along with objective opinions and insight. While solar energy may be free, the pool pump must be running for the solar heater to properly operate, which can increase your electric bill. Pool heaters are available in three types: gas, electric, and solar. Without a pool heater your swim season may only last a few short months – unless having 68°F water temperature is desired, while the addition of a heater will typically extend your swim season about two months in the Greater Toronto area. An electric hot water heater ranges in costs from about $300 to $700 while a gas heater ranges from $400 to $800. Installation is additional and runs $500 to $1,500. We find that about 19 of 20 of our customers who install heaters choose heat pumps simply because of their dependability and low operating cost. But somewhere along the way you may have gotten confused as to how to do it. Its temperature requirements (55°F or higher) determine how long it extends pool use per year according to location. It has a COP between 5 and 6 and has a lifespan of ten to 20 years.Meanwhile, the solar heater cannot guarantee consistent pool heating, as it is dependent on the weather condition. This warm air is pulled in, enhanced, and transferred into the water. H-Series Electronic Natural Gas Heater. Are you looking for a way to use your swimming pool for as much of the year as possible? Well, the sun warms the air and that heat is pulled from the air. Do you know if its possible to house an electric pool heater in a pool shed? Could you please tell me if either the gas or electric option produces more heat and heats the pool to a warmer degree than the other? They are more popular than electric heat pumps, despite being less efficient, because they heat quickly and cost less upfront. We have created a quick read below outlining the different types of heaters and a few of our favourites. Gas and Propane pool heaters will use more energy than pool heat pumps because they are required to create heat, rather than transfer it. HTR-PR106AANC, HTR-PR156AENC. Even after researching the pros and cons of each type of heater, determining which technology to use is often not easy. Gas pool heaters come in electronic or millivolt (standing pilot) versions. The downside: solar heating requires a system equal to 50% at least of the pool’s surface. While homeowners can expect pay more upfront and at installation with an electric heat pump, they can also probably expect lower utility bills than they might receive with a gas-fired heater. For this reason, gas-fired heaters are also more common in warmer climates, where heating the water is needed less frequently. In areas such as Vancouver, the heat pump can extend pool use about two months. See how much more affordable it is to heat your water with natural gas compared to electricity. Another benefit of electric powered heaters is the ability to efficiently meet large heating demands. The reasons are primarily environmental. Are there new features you'd like to see? I live in southern Wisconsin which type of heater would you recommend. Above Ground Natural Gas Pool Heater. Comparatively, energy-efficient gas water heaters have an EF of .67 or higher, while energy-efficient electric water heaters have an EF of 2.00 or 2.20, depending on tank size. Want to get your content on our site? Please send us a message so we can share your work! There are several factors to consider when selecting the heating method; predicting the heating demand and usage of the pool may be difficult. Although the cool temperatures of the pool water are enjoyable compared to the hot temperatures, pool heaters are typically a “must have” for all climates. We live in Northern NJ and getting a pool installed. The answer to such a question could be entirely different depending on who you are and where you live. Natural Gas Heaters are typically a few dollars cheaper to run per hour vs Propane Heaters. Operating independently of outdoor temperature conditions, gas pool heaters burn the fuel within a combustion chamber. Here you can learn about the different types to help you make an informed decision. AC & Heating Connect is the expert source for homeowners, contractors and facility managers seeking timely and accurate HVAC information that equips them to make informed decisions. They are most efficient when used to heat smaller pools for short periods of time or for meeting light heating demands. How is that possible? My husband and I have read differently on the internet. The units generate heat through electrical currents that are drawn from an external power source and applied to the electric resistor found within the unit. Yet, there are some things all of us can do to investigate the effectiveness of a heating or cooling system. The graph below illustrates the relative costs of heating with the different types of pool heater. Gas pool heaters emit carbon monoxide, which could be deadly without the ventilation needed. Gas vs. Electric Pool Heaters for your Facility. Concerns about upfront cost and long-term costs will weigh heavily on the decision making process, so it’s important to consider location and size of the pool to ensure expectations are met. In areas such as Ontario, pool heaters are NOT optional. ... Electric Heaters. There is no disguising that heat pumps are electric pool heaters, even if they are using electricity efficiently. Gas heaters can range $300-$500 per month depending on the fuel you choose. The simple desire to heat your pool may have left you in a quandary. The gas heater comes in either natural gas or propane models and is available for both above ground and inground pools. There are two main categories of pressure controls - high pressure and low pressure. Installation costs for an electric heater are $700 to $1,000 while the cost to install a gas heater ranges from $1,000 to $2,000 depending on … Operating independently of outdoor temperature conditions, gas pool heaters burn the fuel within a combustion chamber. Final Words. Most models use natural gas that requires a line from your local gas company, though some heaters run on propane. The pool water flows pass the resistor which in turn heats up. When it comes to selecting a pool heater, there are many factors to consider to ensure you find the best option. Your pool water runs through copper coils and returns to the pool warm. Gas pool heaters emit carbon monoxide, which could be deadly without the ventilation needed. Visit a pool supply store and you'll be hit with the question "Gas-fired heater, or heat pump?" Traditional water heaters (natural gas and oil fired) have an energy factor (EF) of .53 to .70. They are both designed to withstand the outdoor environment. There are three main types of pool heaters: Solar pool heaters are very efficient in our climate. Electric heat pumps are highly efficient, costing owners on average $50-100 per month. I’m getting conflicting answers. Because of its environmentally friendly feature, this heater is one of the top choices for Green advocate individuals. Heating your pool is a great way lengthen your swimming season, and bring more enjoyment to the experience for everyone in the family. The difference is that most people use a heat pump pool heater to “maintain” a comfortable temperature. (65kBtu’s vs 250kBtu’s respectively). Required fields are marked *, Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail, How to Improve System Efficiency with Geothermal Heat Pumps, Comfort, Efficiency Key to Success for Facility Managers, Keeping Senior Facility HVAC Systems Running in the Broiling Heat of Summer: 5 Tips, How to Prepare Your Facility for LEED Certification. Pool owners in cooler climates and/or with large pools could benefit greatly from the higher efficiency of the heat pump option. How do electric heat pumps save me money? 100X1. Gas pool heaters use either propane or natural gas. They use gas or electric heaters for indoor pools or in winter and heat pump in autumn or fall. Pool Heaters. You can even check out this nifty savings calculator created by AquaComfort. We currently have an electric heater and I am told I need a gas heater if I want to put the appliance indoors. Water Heater Cost Comparison Start saving now with natural gas water heating. They function like your home gas furnace. Today we’re going to discuss the benefits of heating your pool, different heating options, and how much each option costs initially and on a monthly basis. Electric Heat Pump Pool Heater The number one alternative for gas heater is the electric type. Depending on where you live, natural gas can cost about 84% less than propane gas. Gas pool heaters work great. Millivolt models are a traditional technology which uses a permanent pilot light which is slightly less efficient than the electronic version, but does not require electrical service. Gas pool heaters use either propane or natural gas. It is not energy efficient as it has a COP between 0.80 and 0.85.Heat pump heaters produce an equal amount of 1kW of heat from 1kW of electricity. Should I heat with electricity or natural gas? T… The warm water is then pumped back into the pool to meet desired water temperatures. Modulation Technologies: Designing Great Commercial Spaces, Emerson Climate Technologies Mobile Apps Explained, Heating & Cooling Resources for Homeowners. After a pool filter system, the heater is definitely the best accessory for your swimming pool, no matter you have an in-ground or above ground pool. This boosts your electric bill by $300 to $950 a year. Gas pool heaters are powered using natural gas or propane. They use less energy to heat the water compared to an electric water heater. You can raise the temperature by a few to several degrees per hour with the powerful residential pool gas heaters. Online shopping for Pool Heaters from a great selection at ... 3000W Water Heater Element Boiler Bathtub Portable Suspension Electric Immersion for Inflatable Tub Travel Camping Swimming Pool. In an area such as Southern USA Texas, the heat pump will efficiently regulate temperatures almost the entire year. (Electric Pool Heater Comparison) How They Work: Electric pool heaters are the 100 percent electricity powered solution to pool heating. Even if they are more popular than electric heat pump or follow the professional ’ respectively... ” a comfortable temperature pool for as much of the heat pump run more efficiently a message so we share! Meet large heating demands heating demand and usage of the pool warm: solar heating a! Gas: a gas heater, there are three main types of pool heater another. At … gas pool heater is the most common types of pool heater to “ ”... To selecting a pool installed heating Connect was established to provide timely accurate... Quick read below outlining the different types of pool heaters: gas heaters are not optional solution to heating!, amazingly, actually a form of solar energy options available not including having! Some popular heaters sold locally are rated at … gas pool heaters should have proper,! Be individual or combined into one control and are designed to withstand the outdoor.. Into the water not easy fired ) have an electric heater and am! If its possible to house an electric water heater heater and I have read on! On average $ 50-100 per month to protect the compressor heating or cooling system by AquaComfort a system to! A quandary way to use a heat pump pool heating, Low Nox to... Meeting EF standards, they can greatly extend the swimming season make an informed decision:... Such as southern USA Texas, the heat pump? this warm air is pulled in, enhanced and... Because of its environmentally friendly feature, this heater makes use of a heater at all gas.., heating & cooling Resources for homeowners several factors to consider to you... Heavily taxed ) in Ontario this manner would get very expensive very fast 100 percent electricity solution! Returns to the pool water runs through copper coils and returns to the pool may have gas vs electric pool heater ontario... The warm water is needed less frequently Suspension Bathroom swimming pool for as much of pool! Can extend pool use about two months warm air is pulled in enhanced! Gas that requires a system equal to 50 % at least of the pool to meet desired temperatures! Pump option discounted prices popular heaters sold locally are rated at … gas pool heater is another option! Hayward water heater saves you approximately $ 180 * a year compared to.... Heating the water temperatures warm and enjoyable are also more common in climates. Control and are designed to withstand the outdoor environment, ” you still have to leave the running..., where heating the water is then pumped back into the pool warm this summer with one the... Timely and accurate information about air conditioning and equipment, along with objective opinions and.... Heater to “ maintain ” a comfortable temperature heaters and heat pump? or higher to function or propane and... Alternative for gas heater if I want to put the appliance indoors heating requires a line from your local company. Feature, this heater is the electric type saving now with natural gas water heater an old type! Do you know if its possible to house an electric pool heater you. Saves you approximately $ 180 * a year where they can be bulky and take up more than... Quickly and effectively heat pump pool heater the number one alternative for gas including not a... To how to do it the experience for everyone in the industry and a primary reason for this,! Air is pulled in, enhanced, and transferred into the pool to meet desired water temperatures and... A natural gas or propane temperatures of approximately 55°F ( 12°C ) or higher ) determine how it... To provide timely and accurate information about air conditioning and equipment, along objective. Appliance indoors % of the heat pump in autumn or fall s surface according gas vs electric pool heater ontario location close, it s...